Oct 19, 2022 : Tub or Shower – Which Is Right for Your Bathroom?

Are you ready to invest in a bathroom renovation for your NJ home, and trying to decide on the ideal layout for this new space? Many details go into the design for a bathroom renovation, such as the colors, tiles, plumbing fixtures, and more. 

One of the most important decisions you will make is whether you want to install a tub, shower, or a combination of a tub that also has a shower head. Talk to your contractor to compare the pros and cons of each of these options.

Here are a few things to consider when you are working on your plan for a bathroom renovation in NJ.

Pros of Installing a Shower

Not only is a shower convenient, but many other benefits come from this type of bathroom layout. For example, you can create a large, small, or standard shower, depending on the space that is available. 

Additionally, consider other customizable features for your bathroom renovations, such as installing grab bars to make the shower safer and more convenient. Keep reading to learn more about the other benefits you will enjoy with a shower in your bathroom.

Uses Less Water

Consider how many gallons of water are necessary to fill a bathtub. If you need a quick rinse, filling an entire bathtub isn’t practical.

Choose a high-efficiency showerhead and save a lot of water over time. Even if you decrease your water use by a few gallons each day, the savings really add up over time. Not only are you reducing the amount of water you are using (which positively impacts your utility bills), but it also feels good to know that you are protecting the earth simultaneously.

Everyone wants to know that they are doing their part to help with preserving our natural resources. Using less water is one step that can make a difference, starting with a quick shower instead of filling the bathtub.

Saves on Energy

Consider how much money you spend to run the water heater. For example, a lot of hot water is necessary if you are filling a bathtub, compared to the water requirements for a shower. 

Reduce your carbon footprint by minimizing the amount of hot water you use daily. For example, showering is much more convenient and quicker to use than a bathtub. And you will see the savings reflected in your electrical bill. 

Takes Less Floor Space

It can be challenging to fit a big bathtub into a small bathroom. For example, a small bathroom with 13 square feet will be better served with a shower stall installation instead of a full bathtub.

On the other hand, if you are renovating a luxury bathroom with 40 square feet, then there is a lot more space to install an oversized tub. You need to make sure there is plenty of room for other features in the bathroom, such as cupboards and counter space.

Cons of Installing a Shower

Some people feel like a shower installation isn’t the ideal solution for their bathroom remodel. There are definitely pros and cons to all of the options available. Here are a few of the drawbacks to consider.

Requires More Cleaning

There is a lot of surface space in the shower, including the walls, flooring, and door. As a result, you will have more area to scrub every time the bathroom needs to be cleaned. Keeping a shower clean can be a hassle, especially if you have problems with hard water buildup or mold issues.

Harder for Families with Kids and Pets

Walk-in showers are a little more challenging if you need to wash children or pets. Everyone will get wet in the shower, but a tub allows you to keep the water contained, making bath time much easier for children and parents alike. 

Pros of Installing a Tub

As you are considering tubs and showers, look at the benefits of installing a tub. Even if you have a small bathroom, there might still be space available to put in a standard-sized tub. Here are some of the benefits.

Cheaper to Install

A tub can help you save money, especially if you go with cheaper materials. If you are on a budget, talk to your NJ bathroom renovation contractor to compare the pricing and decide whether a shower or tub is a better fit for your family. Tubs are fast and easy to put in, helping to reduce costs for both labor and materials.

Can Go Anywhere in Your Bathroom

There are many options for the positioning of a tub in the bathroom. For example, if you choose a standalone or clawfoot tub, you don’t have to place it directly against the wall. Instead, you might position it at an angle to the wall.


Not only does a bathroom renovation in NJ add value to your home, but you can also improve your quality of living. For example, standard bathtubs are the perfect way to relax at the end of a long day. Draw a bath, drop in some Epsom salt or a bath bomb, then feel your stress melt away as you soak in the tub.

Cons of Installing a Tub

There are a few potential drawbacks to consider for tub installation. Here’s what you need to know. 

Less Accessible

People with mobility issues might have a hard time getting in and out of the tub. Accessiblity is also important to consider if you’re intending to retire in your current home– your needs may change as time goes on. If you need an accessible bathroom, then a shower installation might be a better option. Or, talk to your NJ bathroom renovation contractor about options for walk-in tubs.

Uses More Water

IThe main vessel of a bathtub has a large capacity, which requires a lot of hot water every time you use the tub. If you want to reduce water usage, then it’s better to shower instead of taking a bath.

Takes Up More Space

Also, remember that a bathtub will require more square footage in the room. You need to make sure that enough space is available to fit the tub. So, bathtub installation is better suited for larger bathrooms.

Other Factors to Consider

As you make your final decision, consider if you prefer a combination of a shower and bathtub. You don’t have to stick with a shower only or bathtub only, because many designs allow for both features. The shower-tub combo offers something for everyone and is highly customizable, meaning that you can make whatever choices you need to best suit your family

Brands to Consider

When remodeling your bathroom there are many options to consider for the plumbing fixtures. Magnolia Home Remodeling offers: 

 Financing Options for Kitchen Renovations

When hiring Magnolia Home Remodeling Group you can have peace of mind that all remodeling is performed to exceed your expectations. Additionally, we offer affordable payment plans for all qualified buyers with our 100% Home Improvement Financing for all remodeling projects. Please call us anytime at 855-624-6655 or contact us by filling out the request for an estimate, and we will schedule a free estimate, explaining all the product options and prices available. We appreciate you considering our company to remodel your home!

Contact Magnolia Home Remodeling for Your Bathroom Renovation

What questions do you have about a bathroom renovation? New Jersey homeowners can Reach out to the experts here at Magnolia Home Remodeling Group to learn more. We are always here to help you get answers! Contact us for a consultation.

Visit our bathroom gallery for more pictures of projects we’ve completed!

Prev Post

Next Post

Other Articles by